The MLB The Show 26 Egg Hunt is back, and it’s a great way to earn big rewards while adding some fun challenges to your Diamond Dynasty games. To complete it, you’ll need to find seven colored eggs and finish several "Mystery Missions" to reach 100 program stars. The ultimate reward for full completion is a 90 OVR Jackson Merrill. This guide breaks down each step so you can finish efficiently, with practical tips along the way.

Step 1: Collect the 7 Eggs

Each egg comes from specific tasks in different game modes. After earning an egg, make sure to turn it in through the Egg Hunt Program Collection menu to get progress toward your stars.

  • Orange Egg: Complete all four Egg Hunt Moments in the program menu. These are the easiest way to get early stars.
  • Blue Egg: Capture every territory on the Egg Map Conquest. Plan your route to finish quickly.
  • Yellow Egg: Capture all strongholds on the Egg Map Conquest. Strongholds give more program stars than normal territories.
  • Pink Egg: Earned as a rare or Epic reward from the Egg Hunt Diamond Quest map.
  • Purple Egg: Also a rare/Epic reward from the Diamond Quest map.
  • Red Egg (Bonus): Tally 3 stolen bases in any online multiplayer mode.
  • Green Egg (Bonus): Tally 10 doubles in any online multiplayer mode.

Collecting all eggs first gives you a solid foundation and makes the next step easier.

buy MLB The Show stubs

Step 2: Solve Mystery Missions

Mystery Missions give 10 stars each and often require specific players in your lineup. Completing them smartly can save a lot of time.

Riddle How to Complete
Wait a Third… Win 1 game with Gold Clay Holmes (Yankees Team Affinity).
Customizable Mini Seasons Length Earn 500 PXP with players wearing jersey #7 or #28 in Mini Seasons.
Conq Mysterymaxxing Get 1 Extra Base Hit (XBH) with Troy Tulowitzki in Conquest.
I’m Blue Win 1 game with Kerry Wood (Common Courtesy Program).
Whoops, He’s Not Supposed to Be There Pitch 1 inning with A.J. Puk (Live Series or BR draft).
KYLE TEST Hit a Home Run with Kyle Schwarber (or any "Kyle") in Diamond Quest.
Back Get 1 XBH with Nolan Arenado.
Back-to-Back Get 1 XBH with Nolan Gorman.
Back-to-Back-to-Back Get 1 XBH with Juan Yepez.
Back-to-Back-to-Back-to-Back Get 1 XBH with Dylan Carlson.

Fastest Completion Tips

  1. Stack Your Lineup: The "Back" missions (Arenado, Gorman, Yepez, and Carlson) can be combined into one game. By hitting multiple XBH in the same session, you knock out four missions at once.
  2. Conquest Efficiency: Play the Egg Map Conquest map first. These short 3-inning games allow you to also complete the Tulowitzki, Holmes, Wood, and Puk missions while earning Blue and Yellow eggs.
  3. Online Shortcut: For the Red and Green eggs, use Events rather than Ranked games. Events give faster innings and less competitive play, making it easier to rack up stolen bases and doubles.

Extra Tip for Quick Progress

If you want to save time and focus on gameplay rather than farming, consider using U4N. It’s a trusted platform used by competitive players to skip the boring grind and focus on practicing. You can buy MLB The Show stubs safely and get instant delivery, letting you unlock top cards and complete the Egg Hunt faster without missing out on fun gameplay.

By following this step-by-step approach—starting with the Moments, stacking missions in Conquest, and handling the online bonuses efficiently—you’ll reach 100 stars quickly and claim the 90 OVR Jackson Merrill. Efficient planning and smart use of your lineup is key, and if you want to speed things even more, U4N is a solid, safe way to buy MLB The Show stubs and cut down on grinding time.